Planer

An ESRC Investment
Esrc_logo
  • Home
  • About
  • Research
  • Events
  • Blog
  • Join
Home Is the nexus relevant on the ground?

Is the nexus relevant on the ground?

Blog post by Susan Conlon, PhD Candidate at the Water Security Research Centre, School of International Development, University of East Anglia.

The ‘Is the nexus relevant on the ground?’ session at the Nexus, resource conflicts and social justice was very useful for a relative newcomer to nexus thinking like myself.

In this session, Jeremy Allouche offered alternative framings of the nexus – see blog post The nexus: a management system, policy process or a way of life? In the same session, Alma Lopez-Aviles (University of Surrey) and Christian Stein (IDS) offered insights into the nexus “on the ground”, both giving examples from their research in Ethiopia. These spoke to Jeremy’s way of life and policy process framings of the nexus, respectively.

There can be no doubt about the relevance of the nexus on the ground – of the link between energy, food and the economy – according to Alma. She questioned the potential contribution of dam construction, driven by nexus concerns, to improving livelihoods around Lake Tana, Ethiopia, but found opportunities in small reservoirs and micro-dam construction in apple and bamboo plantations – that can regulate seasonal flooding and prevent contamination. These kinds of projects help to make people aware of the rights as a stakeholder in integrated water management.

sugar_7171887442_f6661d2e57_kCristian Stein looked at the dynamics of the organizations involved in irrigated sugarcane plantations. While he found that organizations were constructing their own interpretations of the nexus, he traced patterns in the discourses, which reflected the importance of interdependencies, the lack of integration and the focus on implementation of normative recommendations.

For Cristian, the nexus is about the negotiation of processes to find some common ground and locate interdependencies across institutions.

Having heard all three talks, I fear that in efforts to understand the nexus ‘on the ground’, there is the risk that yet another new vocabulary is introduced into local communities that serves to advance managerial approaches, albeit unintentionally, and distances people from their right to determine particular ways of life, whether or not these ways of life reflect nexus thinking, as defined by outside ‘experts’.

It remains to be seen whether the use of this terminology in the context of livelihoods, and the actions it produces, is enhancing local people’s wellbeing and rights.

 

About the author

Susan Conlon is a PhD Candidate in the School of International Development and part-time Coordinator of UEA’s Water Security Research Centre. Susan carried out ethnographic research with a campesino community in north-west Peru in 2014, an area where claims are being made that glacier retreat is already impacting water supplies. Her research explores how livelihood practices and choices are influenced by water security discourses and action, and how these discourses are shaped in turn by the language of climate change, adaptation and sustainability. Her interests lie in the paradoxes between what people say and do, which has particular import for understanding situated concerns and priorities in an area juggling socio-economic change with policy and institutional change in water management practices.

 

Image credit: fishing on Lake Tana, with thanks to A.Davey; sugar cane with thanks to Kris Fricke on flickr.


Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)

Related

Mar 7, 2016 The Nexus Network
Tweet
Follow @uk_nexus
2 years ago about, environment, food, partners, people, sustainability, waterdam, irrigation, Lake Tana, resource conflicts, social justice, sugar cane1,994
The Nexus Network
The nexus: a management system, policy process or a way of life?Domestic nexus findings
You Might Also Like
 
Natural Bridge workshop
 
Nexus2020 business report

Nexus logo social

Nexus Network on Twitter
Tweets by @
Explore the site
Contact

Research coordinator: Cian O’Donovan

Media and communications: Becky Ayre

Email: info@thenexusnetwork.org

 

about the nexus network

The Nexus Network has been the first in a series of linked investments from the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) in the UK supporting a community of researchers and stakeholders to tackle nexus interdependencies, trade-offs and decision-making processes. Read more.

2015. The Nexus Network. Website designed, developed and maintained by Atoms and Bits Ltd.